The Wall of Detectives

A hand pinning a blank post-it note to a board of clues

The greatest detectives are sometimes those who listen, rather than those who ask questions. That’s not generally true, but it is how we fill out our wall of detectives. The listener who submits the best guesses and theories earns a place on our illustrious wall.


A medium’s office with with a large “Solved” stamp layered on top

Mystery of the Murdered Medium

Our Divination Detective: Eric Sutherland

Eric correctly guessed the killer’s motivation, and the method of murder, down to the precise interaction. Of course, they also provided additional info, which wasn’t all correct…


A seagull perched by a beach. A “solved” stamp is superimposed on top

The Body on the Beach

Our Seaside Sherlock: Bree Newton-Brown

Bree earned the wall due to their sheer number of correct statements, as well as a theory Dani wished she’d included. Of course, they also immediately changed their mind, but we’ll ignore that…


Palm trees in silhouette with a “solved” stamp overlaid on top

Poison in the Pacific

Our Island Investigator: Laura Scafati

Laura honed in on the murderer straight away, and for exactly the right reasons. They tweeted about their nerves before submitting their guess, but had no reason to be nervous!


Looking down onto the top of a penthouse. “Solved” has been stamped on top

Drowning at the Dinner Party

Our Penthouse Poirot: Ashley & Eric Sutherland

Our two winners came in with a very in depth breakdown two episodes in, and refined it as they went.


A cabin on a lake with a large stamp reading “solved” on top

Rope and the Rich Kids

Our Summercamp Sleuths: Duke and Duchess Trevor and Ashley

When it came to picking the real culprit, our winners identified them quickly and with a brilliant breakdown of why.


hh solved.png

The Hairdresser Homicide

Our Baker Street Beautician: Tyler Erbele

Not only did Tyler find out killer, but they also discovered our secret tells.


a plane cabin with a large "solved" sign overlaid

The In-flight Incident

Our Mile-high Marples: Trevor and Michele

After episode 3, Trevor and Michele had an almost perfect account of the crime, and the movements everyone had made. Nothing got past them!